When your child is frightened of Santa

Do not make them sit on his knee. A large stranger in an unfamiliar costume, in a queue, is a lot to ask of a small child, and the fear passes far faster when nobody forces the meeting.

The personalized Santa video is not taking orders yet. What is available now, in about a minute, is the North Pole Archive — a letter from Santa, a Nice List certificate, the Christmas Eve note and the sleigh docket, $9.99.

This is ordinary, not a problem

Wariness of an unfamiliar adult in an elaborate costume is a young child doing exactly what they should. It is most common somewhere between about two and four, which is also the age at which parents most want the photograph.

Children who are not pushed usually come round on their own, sometimes within the same visit. Children who are put on a lap while crying tend to remember it, and the following year is harder rather than easier.

What helps in the moment

  • Stand where they can watch other children go first, from a distance they choose
  • Wave from where you are, and treat leaving without a meeting as a perfectly good outcome
  • Let them hold something of their own — the meeting is easier with a familiar object in hand
  • Go early, when the queue is short and the room is quiet
  • Take the photograph with you in it, or skip the photograph

What makes it worse

Handing a crying child to a stranger for a picture, however brief, teaches them that saying no about their own body does not work. That is a much bigger thing than a missed photo.

So does teasing about it afterwards, and so does trying again immediately with a different Santa. If the first attempt did not work, the second one on the same day will not either.

Meeting Santa without meeting Santa

Some children are entirely happy with Santa as an idea and only frightened of the man in the queue. Books, films and letters all give them Santa with no stranger attached, and that is usually the version that builds the confidence.

A message from Santa watched at home works the same way: familiar room, no queue, no lap, and they can stop it whenever they like. For a child who is not ready for the grotto, it is often the first version of Santa they enjoy.

Questions

Why is my child scared of Santa?

Because an unfamiliar adult in an elaborate costume is genuinely a lot for a small child, particularly between about two and four. It is a normal reaction, not a problem to fix.

Should I make my child sit on Santa’s knee for a photo?

No. Handing over a crying child for a picture teaches them that saying no about their own body does not work, which matters more than the photograph.

How do I help them enjoy Santa anyway?

Give them Santa without the stranger: books, films, letters, or a message watched at home where they control it. Most children come round on their own once nothing is being forced.

While you are here

  • “But we do not have a chimney”

    The question every child in a flat eventually asks. Four answers that hold up, and the one approach that works better than any of them.

  • A personalized Santa video that knows the little things

    A personalized Santa video where Santa mentions the small, specific things only your family knows. Made for children aged 2 to 10. $24.99.

  • What goes in a Christmas Eve box

    What to put in a Christmas Eve box so the evening slows down instead of speeding up, and the one thing worth leaving out of it.

  • North Pole Rescue

    A present that did not arrive, no chimney, two homes, away for Christmas: an official North Pole notice and a letter from Santa that explains it to your child. $6.99.

Santa knows more than you think.

Tell Santa the small things nobody else knows, and he will tell them back.